An Open Letter to Commissioners of the 217th General Assembly of the PC(USA)
Dear Brothers and Sisters in Christ,
Greetings from the beautiful Shenandoah Valley of Virginia! As you represent the larger church in Birmingham, please know that we are praying for the leading of the Holy Spirit in all your deliberations.
Though there are many important matters coming before this Assembly, the issue that concerns us most is any attempt to remove or 'move around' the fidelity/chastity standards for ordination in G-6.0106b. These are Biblical standards which have been ratified through the amendment process and reaffirmed by several votes in the Presbyteries over the past several years. The PC(USA) has spoken repeatedly on maintaining these standards. The last vote on fidelity/chastity in 2001 revealed that 73% of the Presbyteries favor maintaining our current standards. Recent studies show that only 25% of church members approve of the ordination of sexually active homosexual persons.
But now, at this 217th General Assembly, you are being asked to approve a new Authoritative Interpretation (recommendation # 5 in the PUP report) which by a simple majority at this GA will turn our polity on its head and open the door to the ordination of self-affirming, practicing, unrepentant homosexual persons. And remember, we in the Presbyteries will not get the opportunity to debate and vote on this new AI proposed in recommendation # 5 of the PUP report! That's just not the Presbyterian way!!
It took the PUP Task Force 4 years of intensive study and discernment to come up with this report and its' recommendations. And though they have encouraged the church to move beyond "yes/no polarities", discouraging up or down votes, that's precisely what they are asking you to do… vote up or down on a new Authoritative Interpretation which, we believe, will bring pandemonium to the PC(USA), not peace and unity to our already divided… declining church.
We implore you, do not vote to remove our existing ordination standards or adopt a new Authoritative Interpretation that will put the PC(USA) in the untenable position of professing to hold Biblical standards of fidelity and chastity, while at the same time treating obedience and compliance to those very standards as optional . This "third way" to peace and unity comes at the expense of our theological purity and creates a hypocritical polity that will promote a creeping congregationalism in our cherished connectional form of government.
This is a critical time in the life of our beloved denomination. Please help us protect
G-6.0106b and defeat the proposed AI in recommendation # 5 of the PUP report.
Grace and Peace,
The Session of First Presbyterian Church on Court Square,
Harrisonburg, Virginia